Here comes the masturbatory docuseries

November 26th, 2011 | By | 11 Comments »

Barry McGee for Wynwood Walls

Wynwood Walls is a noteworthy mural program in the Wynwood District of Miami. It has brought a number talented of artists to Miami to paint walls, and I’m under the impression that these artists are rewarded handsomely for their work. So far, so good. The project was started by Tony Goldman, a real estate developer. For this reason, Wynwood Walls has always been a bit controversial. To put it simply, Goldman is banking on commissioned murals by street artists and graffiti artists/writers to help quickly gentrify the neighborhood of Wynwood, where his company has significant property holdings. Okay, so that’s going to be controversial, but personally I think both sides of that issue have some good points. While Wynwood Walls has made me uncomfortable in the past with their high-culture and very dollar-sign focused take on murals, at the end of the day Wynwood has more walls painted by great artists because of Wynwood Walls and the neighborhood is on the upswing. But I’m digressing with history and politics before I even get to my main point: Wynwood Walls was not the first mural project in Wynwood, nor the largest, nor the most important. Before Wynwood Walls came along, the district was known in the street art and graffiti worlds for Primary Flight, quite likely the largest mural festival ever held with over 250 participants since 2007. While Primary Flight is not going to have quite as strong of a presence this year as it has in years past (both festivals are held over the first week of December), Primary Flight has undoubtedly been the superior festival to Wynwood Walls in size and the locations of walls in the past. This year, Wynwood Walls has ramped things up and Primary Flight has slowed things down, so it remains to be seen which will be the bigger festival, but the idea of Wynwood as a mural district certainly stems from Primary Flight’s work. Wynwood Walls took a version of Primary Flight’s idea, added their personal spin to it and started up a few years later in the same neighborhood as Primary Flight.

Given that history, I at first found it surprising that a recent docuseries about Wynwood is telling such a different story: Here Comes The Neighborhood. The series is described as “a Short-Form Docuseries exploring the power of Public Art and innovation to uplift and revitalize urban communities,” and supposedly tells the story of how Wynwood has been improved by murals. Unfortunately, the series is not at all what it claims. Tony Goldman, the man behind Wynwood Walls, is the executive producer of Here Comes The Neighborhood. When you know that, it becomes a lot more clear as to why the video series is, so far, a bit of a circle-jerk of Wynwood Walls participants talking about how great the project is, save for about 20 seconds mentioning Primary Flight and Gaia’s joke that the main Wynwood Walls complex might be “where art goes to die, to a certain extent.”

The Wynwood Walls website and the Here Comes The Neighbordhood website are even worse, with absolutely no mention of Primary Flight or the graffiti and street art in Wynwood that preceded either festival. Of course people and companies can say what they want about their projects so Wynwood Walls and this video series could just tell the story of Wynwood Walls and not mention Primary Flight, but I do take issue with them claiming to tell a history of art in the area and practically writing out the organization responsible for the majority of Wynwood’s murals. Based on a quick estimate, the Here Comes The Neighborhood trailer includes at least 6 of the murals affiliated with Primary Flight rather than Wynwood Walls, as were 8 artists affiliated with Primary Flight rather than Wynwood Walls, 9 artists shown who worked with Primary Flight before Wynwood Walls and 1 who worked with both Primary Flight and Wynwood Walls during her first trip to Miami. So clearly the makers of Here Comes The Neighborhood like and know about the murals for which Primary Flight is responsible, but have for some unknown reason neglected to give Primary Flight due credit for their contribution to Wynwood.

So with their twisting of history in mind, here’s the trailer for and the first two episodes of Here Comes The Neighborhood, which at least does show some great artwork if you can get past their gross distortions:

Photo by Hargo

Category: Featured Posts, Videos | Tags: , , ,
  • Marcus

    Tony Goldman did the same thing with SoHo in the late 70’s early 80’s. He’s a real estate developer who uses artists to gentrify neighborhoods, attracting creative types to formerly blighted areas.

  • Local Florida newspaper & TV coverage, for years, often generically referred to Primary Flight’s annual mural festival as “The Wynwood Walls” and “The Walls of Wynwood” in their articles and photo essays (These were murals on walls in a neighborhood named Wynwood, after all). It was after this became a commonly used descriptor of the Primary Flight festival that a new, competing festival project was launched by Goldman titled “The Wynwood Walls”. 


    The people who run Primary Flight are full of themselves 1

  • Perhaps, but it seems that the organizers of Wynwood Walls are then also full of themselves. Maybe a similar video series produced by Primary Flight would be equally problematic and inaccurate. We don’t know, because those videos do not exist. What we do have is Here Comes The Neighborhood, and it is misleading about the history of murals in Wynwood.

  • Medusamod

    If the people who ran Primary Flight had been nice to deal with and not so condescending to those who showed interest in their work they may have not faded from the scene. I am glad that Goldman has  overshadowed them. They aren’t very ice people.

  • Medusamod

    If they had treated the general public who showed interest in their work with some respect maybe they would have had a better outcome. My experience with Primary Flight is  awful. They are quite snobby in my opinion and do not foster inclusion of the general public. They too are all abut money and promotion.

  • Medusamod

    My name is Street Art and I sent you a request to be your friend on Facebook.

  • Medusamod

    One last comment. It really doesn’t matter that Goldman used artists to promote his development. What matters is the community has been enriched culturally.

  • 1972

    Americans and Northern Europeans that piled and exploited the whole world throughout century’s (something about to change).  Rich and Privileged people, trying to be socialists and part time anarchists, that would call the cops if someone was tagging yours walls. Criticizing others for doing the same, specially that annoying RJ with is dad and is huge collection of “STREET ART”… Fucking Hypocrites…

    Please grow up, lose your rich complex, being poor is not cool.
    If you buy art and care about this shit called street art by your peers, is because you own a house and don´t get 300 pounds per month to live.

    Props for those who cash in from this shit they call street art and still do graffiti and support their-ones.

  • Katherineadelle

    OK, i’m starting to feel confused about where our critical thinking about art and geography resides.  Like RJ I really get what you’re saying that this project is being funded in such a way that they have sort of a monopoly on  the representation of local mural projects, and how it’s not very attractive as a project.  but is that really the central discussion? i think we need to start addressing street art and gentrification with a little more consideration of the full communities affected.  like when you say “the neighborhood is on the upswing” i think that needs to be defined more, flushed out, represented as the complicated thing that it is.  

    or like in the comments, when medusamod you say that “what matters is that the community has been enriched culturally” i would like to understand more fully what you mean by that.  whose culture? which community?

    RJ you make a great point when you say that “here comes the neighborhood” is misleading about the history of murals in wynwood.  it’s also really misleading about Wynwood! and that’s where i want us to be talking about in the scene.  otherwise references to “the community” are sincerely cheapened by their position as an object in an aesthetic world, instead of many subjects creating our mutual world.

  • Pingback: Wynwood Walls in Miami | Visualingual()