Dear Snyder, please be more creative

June 2nd, 2012 | By | 16 Comments »

One of Snyder's recent pieces. Photo by Snyder

Update: This post should have been about Snyder’s lack of originality rather than a lack of creativity. As pointed out in the comments, Snyder has been drawing Doodle for many years. While perhaps creative, I still find much of Snyder’s work, particularly this piece, to be unoriginal. Maybe that’s worse.

From time to time, I have posted about Snyder. He seems like an enthusiastic artist, and that’s commendable. He also as a talent for finding good placement for his pieces.

Sure, Snyder’s best work was always a fair amount like something Banksy would or had come up with, but I tried to ignore that and find the positives about Snyder’s work. After all, how many contemporary stencil artists can say that they’ve never been a bit too inspired by Banksy at least once?

A classic Banksy. Photo by Wokka

And then Snyder introduced a character into his work whom he named Doodle. Okay, the character looks like a stenciled version of Dran’s character whom Dran named Scribble, and they are pretty much the same character. Both are slightly mischievous young artists. Again, this alone was frustrating, but Dran isn’t particularly well-known outside of Europe, so maybe Snyder, who is based in LA, hadn’t heard of him. Maybe it was just a coincidence.

Dran's Scribble character. Photo by Marie Aschehoug-Clauteaux

And then I saw the stencil by Snyder at the top of this post, which is actually one of at least two in a series of similar pieces. Again, I was reminded of Banksy and of Dran, even a specific piece by Banksy (the maid, shown above). But now another artist came to mind too: Saber. Revealing tags beneath the buff is pretty much exactly like Saber’s Ripped Tag series of canvases. Saber’s canvases are significantly better executed than Synder’s work, but the similarities are clear.

A painting from Saber's "Ripped Tags" series. Photo by Lois Stavsky

At first, I saw Snyder’s clear Banksy influence and I thought that it was a phase. I thought that he would eventually grow out of it and get his own style. Influences are one thing, but Snyder goes beyond that. As time has gone on, it is clear that Snyder has not only failed to develop a personal style, but he has perhaps even increased his reliance on the ideas of other artists.

This buff/zipper piece goes too far. It’s actually not a bad idea. But it is quite transparently 3 other artists’ ideas mashed into one with little original content added by Snyder.

As flattering as it may seem for artists’ to be inspired others’ work, at the heart of this issue is pretty simple: if you are going to take inspiration from others’ work or blatantly rip their ideas, then do it better and make it your own. Snyder has clearly done neither and that in itself is disappointing at best.

Photos Snyder, Wokka, Marie Aschehoug-Clauteaux and Lois Stavsky

Category: Featured Posts, Photos, Random | Tags: , , ,
  • http://twitter.com/_yote Yotes

    don’t know much about Snyder… but it almost sounds like you are saying Banksy and Saber invented trompe l’oeil?

  • http://blog.vandalog.com/ RJ Rushmore

    I hope it doesn’t read that way. Of course countless artists have used
    trompe l’œil. But not every example of trompe l’œil is as closely related to Snyder’s work as these pieces by Banksy and Saber. And it’s clear from other work by Snyder that he is looking closely at Banksy for inspiration. For example, this also looks like something very much inspired by Banksy – http://melroseandfairfax.blogspot.com/2011/03/shootin-blanks.html

  • MELROSEandFAIRFAX

    C’mon RJ, what is this?  You are bringing your own relationships and associations to Snyder’s work, and unfairly judging him by that. You are calling Snyder out for quality pieces that somewhat resemble some things that great artist’s have done, but Snyder’s are independent works that stand on their own.  I can’t speak for Snyder on all aspects but I do know that he has been drawing his Doodle characters his entire life, and was not influenced by Dran or others.  You can ask his mom for some of his early ‘doodles’ dating back decades.  As for the zipping, sure, it reveals what is behind the wall like Banksy’s maid piece, but Snyder’s piece is quite different.  It is placed at one of LA’s hottest street art spots, and placed right after a buff, so Snyder’s piece is trying to suggest that if you dig beneath the layers, the art is here.  It works perfectly.  And as for the basketball link that you posted in the comments above, it is only similar to Banksy in that both artist’s have a gift for skillfully utilizing the inherent environment in their art.  The basketball piece is downright brilliant, and one of my personal favorite street art pieces of all time.  It is so very well done.   This is your blog, but I don’t know understand why you would launch a personal attack on such a talented artist like Snyder.  His art is solid.  Snyder has his own style.   And the street art fans who follow it would agree that it is the farthest thing from disappointing–its pretty awesome.  I hear that Snyder just finished a new piece today–can’t wait to see it!

  • Mike J

    If you are willing to put the time then you will find the root to all art. Not just Snyder’s. 

    RJ, please stop “bringing your own relationships and associations” because that’s how you lose viewers, ask Melrose and Fairfax he’ll tell you. 

    PS. Don’t start a “rock” band. 

  • Eric

    Any exposure is good exposure for Snyder! He must be doing something right if his name is being mentioned alongside such artists as Banksy, Dran and Saber. There’s nothing wrong with being inspired by some of top notch leaders of the street art world. Keep up the good work! 

  • wasabi letdown

    SO WHAT. I know a lot of street art blogs that look identical to yours, I didn’t put that on my blog. Let people create.

  • LauraK58

    I must take exception to your rude comments about Bryan Snyder’s artwork. First of all his character Doodles has been documented as being an early childhood drawing. There is proof available in case you are wondering. To slam an up-and-coming artist in your blog is just wrong on so many levels.  He is a talented young man with a very creative mind. He is a local guy and has been instrumental in furthering the interests in art in Carlsbad.  You need to reseach your subject more thoroughly. Artist slamming other artist’s work is not cool at all.

  • Guest

    I have had the wonderful privilege of working with Snyder on an amazing piece he recently completed on Melrose.  He created the piece after two very deserving girls as a surprise to them.  He created the doodle, an absolute original, and I had the amazing experience of watching it from start to finish.  I will say that this man is not only a great talent, but that he is inspired of his own creativity.  Of course he probably uses other artists as inspiration, but isn’t that the point of looking up to others?  It’s like saying that because you started a blog, you are like Perez Hilton?  No.  Someone had a great idea and that is where street art was born and really every artist that has followed has incorporated that very idea, along with every other, into making their own statement!  On that note, I saw the new piece on Melrose and it rocks!  In the famed phrase of street art, “Stay Up!’  Don’t let some silly discouragement get you down :)

  • Whakoallday80

    Coming up with something original is hard to do, we all know this. This blog, for instance, was inspired by other blogs. Frankly, I think you ripped this idea for a blog about street art from someone else. On a more personal note, Snyder is a really cool, down to earth guy who not only creates original and thoughtful street art but successfully ran his own studio and gallery in his hometown, inspiring people in the community to love and appreciate art. His canvas pieces are very well thought out and impressive and are currently hung all over our town as well as his street art pieces that don’t get buffed for a reason. So go ahead and say that he is unoriginal, but don’t forget that you are as well.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001842416538 Fitzroy Flasher

    I don’t deny the value of critique, and even enjoyed reading this post, but respectfully disagree completely.  The point I take issue with is the criticism of Snyder for being inspired by someone else.  Who is not derivative at the end of the day? I can think of a dozen street artists who have used images of people coming out of walls, painting walls, lifting curtains on walls etc.  I think it is fair to say each art movement has a theme, look or philosophical position and within that, artists can be grouped.  Are taggers all derivative rip offs of the first person to ever write on a wall?  And what of writers pieces.  Not to mention the cast of thousands of illustrators providing us with delicate little characters.  I disagree that there is any blatancy here.  I even disagree that it is Banksy that Snyder is derivative of.  

  • http://blog.vandalog.com/ RJ Rushmore

    I appreciate everyone letting me know about Doodle being something that Snyder has been doing for a while. To be honest, it’s actually something I had discussed with him quite a while ago and had forgotten about.

    Nonetheless, as I say in the update to this post, I still think much of his work is unoriginal and pretty much just recycles a lot of ideas that are floating around right now without adding anything unique or particularly noteworthy.

  • http://blog.vandalog.com/ RJ Rushmore

    Thank you for your honest engagement rather than using ad hominem attacks to defend Snyder. I disagree with you, but real appreciate the engagement.

    That’s a great point that everyone is derivative. I suppose what often sets artists apart for me even when their work is somewhat derivative is that a great artist should add their own spin or a particularly skillful hand to whatever old ideas they are playing with. For the most part, I don’t think Snyder does those things, but I think he may have the potential to do so, because he does do things like practice great placement.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001842416538 Fitzroy Flasher

    Thanks.  Yeah that’s true that a great artist should add their own spin, I suppose whether that spin is evident is in the eye of the beholder.  I do take your point though.  And thank you – debate is far more interesting than argument every time!

  • Ron

    Bryan has been advancing the vibrancy and spontaneity of of the arts in our town for years. Always the first to step up and get involved to bring art to the people. Our quality and personal vision as artists grows and develops with time. My hope is that he learns from your comments to dig deeper ,even if they are less than encouraging and that you learn that a hammering is not always the most valuable way to inspire the artist to a more creative place.

  • Mgose123

    Might I suggest purchasing Bob Dylan’s 1st, self-titled record. While I think ALL of the tracks will help establish my argument in defense of Snyder’s “stealing” the creative statements of other, more well-known artists, I think track 5 of side 2 best emphasizes the point. Or for that matter, why not listen to any musical statement Pete Seeger EVER made. Perchance you have never encountered a Hip Hop Artist blatantly sampling the works of other artists. Have you even heard of William Shakespeare? As T.S. Elliot not only famously expressed, but in fact built his legacy embodying, “Good Poets Borrow, Great Poets Steal.” The truth is that art is a communal experience, and to claim that one artist can own a particular variation of expression is fallacy. Here, you compose writing so boldly as if you invented language itself. Where is your original statement? Condemning an artist for his public works is equally as old a practice as artists being inspired by others. Perhaps what we witness in Snyder is the humble first steps in what may evolve into an epic artistic voyage. Or perhaps, we simply see one individual boldly perusing his passion. Yes, maybe he uses a conglomeration of familiar voices, but what better way to draw attention then to use the best, most well known voices and images in order to publicize one’s own messages? Snyder doesn’t deny his roots. Perhaps in criticizing the particular aesthetics of some of his pieces, you miss his over all quality as an artist and agent for pursuing and inspiring the closet artists of San Diego to go after it with all they have, not fearing to hesitate because they aren’t “cool,” or “edgy,” or “original,” enough to pacify the critics.

  • http://blog.vandalog.com/ RJ Rushmore

    Good artists borrow and great artists steal. That’s true enough. But the truly great artists who steal improve upon their predecessors. Additionally, it has always seemed to me, and I may be alone here, that the stealing should be done to reintroduce ideas/styles/whatever that have been neglected. In this case, Snyder is recycling from his contemporaries who do work better than he does to begin with.

    If recycling well-known and popular ideas and then executing them with less skill than the contemporaries from which they are stealing/borrowing is great art, then Snyder should be given a show in MoMA alongside Mr. Brainwash.